The Paradox of Mineral Downstreaming: An Economic Analysis of Mining Regulatory Disharmony in Indonesia
Abstract
Although Indonesia’s mineral downstreaming policy aims to enhance value added, its implementation is impeded by fundamental regulatory disharmony. This study aims to evaluate the legal framework of the downstreaming policy to identify inconsistencies and to examine its substantive provisions from an EAL perspective. Employing an interdisciplinary legal research method, this study applies a RIA framework to analyze secondary data comprising statutory instruments and relevant literature. The findings reveal that the policy’s legal framework, while vertically coherent, suffers from severe horizontal disharmony with environmental and spatial planning laws. This disharmony is proven to create significant economic inefficiencies, negative externalities, and high-cost legal uncertainty. The study concludes that active regulatory intervention is a necessity. Therefore, a multi-track strategy is recommended: first, the issuance of precise implementing regulations as a short-term solution; second, the parallel strengthening of non-regulatory interventions; and third, a long-term legislative harmonization agenda.
Downloads
References
The 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia. https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang-dasar
Auty, R. (1993). Sustaining Development in Mineral Economies: The Resource Curse Thesis. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203422595
Bentham, J. (2000). An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. Batoche Books Limited.
Busthami, D. S. (2022). The Principles of Good Legislation Forming: A Critical Review. SIGn Jurnal Hukum, 4(2), 308-319. https://doi.org/10.37276/sjh.v4i2.223
Deddy, M. A., Adriyanto, A., & Navalino, R. D. A. (2023). Strategi Hilirisasi di Indonesia dalam Menghadapi Kebijakan Larangan Ekspor Bijih Nikel Terhadap Tingkat Pengangguran dan Cadangan Devisa Negara. JISIP (Jurnal Ilmu Sosial dan Pendidikan), 7(3), 2026-2032. https://doi.org/10.58258/jisip.v7i3.5137
Government Regulation in Lieu of Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 2 of 2022 on Job Creation (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2022 Number 238, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6841). https://peraturan.go.id/id/perppu-no-2-tahun-2022
Government Regulation of the Republic of Indonesia Number 78 of 2010 on Reclamation and Post-Mining (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2010 Number 138, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 5172). https://peraturan.go.id/id/pp-no-78-tahun-2010
Government Regulation of the Republic of Indonesia Number 96 of 2021 on the Implementation of Mineral and Coal Mining Business Activities (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2021 Number 208, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6721). https://peraturan.go.id/id/pp-no-96-tahun-2021
Government Regulation of the Republic of Indonesia Number 25 of 2024 on Amendment to Government Regulation Number 96 of 2021 on the Implementation of Mineral and Coal Mining Business Activities (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2024 Number 89, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6921). https://peraturan.go.id/id/pp-no-25-tahun-2024
Gunningham, N., & Sinclair, D. (2017). Smart Regulation. In P. Drahos (Ed.), Regulatory Theory: Foundations and Applications (pp. 133-148). ANU Press.
Hidayat, A., Sugiarto, L., Sulistianingsih, D., Ananta, B. R., & Syakur, M. A. A. (2024). Study of Regulatory and Institutional Framework for the Relocation of the National Capital in Indonesia. Journal of Law and Legal Reform, 5(4), 1821-1880. Retrieved from https://journal.unnes.ac.id/journals/jllr/article/view/13566
International Trade Organization. (1947, October 30). General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (The WTO Agreement: GATT 1947). https://www.wto.org/english/docs_e/legal_e/gatt47_e.htm
Irwansyah. (2020). Penelitian Hukum: Pilihan Metode & Praktik Penulisan Artikel. Mirra Buana Media.
Islam, M. M., Sohag, K., Mamman, S. O., & Herdhayinta, H. (2024). Response of Indonesian Mineral Supply to Global Renewable Energy Generation: Analysis Based on Gravity Model Approach. Geoscience Frontiers, 15(4), 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gsf.2023.101658
Khoiro, E. U. (2024). Kebijakan Hilirisasi Sumber Daya Alam Mineral di Indonesia: Analisis Bibliometrik. Jurnal Edueco, 7(2), 131-137. https://doi.org/10.36277/edueco.v7i2.242
Krustiyati, A., & Gea, G. V. V. (2023). The Paradox of Downstream Mining Industry Development in Indonesia: Analysis and Challenges. Sriwijaya Law Review, 7(2), 335-349. https://doi.org/10.28946/slrev.Vol7.Iss2.2734.pp335-349
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 5 of 1960 on Basic Provisions of Agrarian Principles (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 1960 Number 104, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 2043). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/1361
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6 of 1994 on Ratification of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 1994 Number 42, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 3557). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/486
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 7 of 1994 on Ratification of the Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 1994 Number 57, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 3564). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/487
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 25 of 2007 on Capital Investment (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2007 Number 67, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 4724). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/104
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 26 of 2007 on Spatial Planning (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2007 Number 68, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 4725). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/105
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 4 of 2009 on Mineral and Coal Mining (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2009 Number 4, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 4959). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/520
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 32 of 2009 on Environmental Protection and Management (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2009 Number 140, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 5059). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/561
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 12 of 2011 on Legislation Making (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2011 Number 82, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 5234). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/249
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 23 of 2014 on Local Government (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2014 Number 244, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 5587). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/1605
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 15 of 2019 on Amendment to Law Number 12 of 2011 on Legislation Making (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2019 Number 183, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6398). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/1749
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 3 of 2020 on Amendment to Law Number 4 of 2009 on Mineral and Coal Mining (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2020 Number 147, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6525). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/1763
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 13 of 2022 on the Second Amendment to Law Number 12 of 2011 on Legislation Making (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2022 Number 143, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6801). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/1801
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6 of 2023 on Enactment of Government Regulation in Lieu of Law Number 2 of 2022 on Job Creation Into Law (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2023 Number 41, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6856). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/1825
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 59 of 2024 on the 2025-2045 National Long-Term Development Plan (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2024 Number 194, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6987). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/1902
Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 2 of 2025 on the Fourth Amendment to Law Number 4 of 2009 on Mineral and Coal Mining (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2025 Number 29, Supplement to the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia Number 7100). https://www.dpr.go.id/dokumen/jdih/undang-undang/detail/1996
Lazuardi, S. D., Hadi, F., Devintasari, D. V., Wuryaningrum, P., Riduwan, M., Noarista, O. S., & Alifia, S. F. (2024). The Impact on Downstream Policy Implementation for Mineral Export Products in Indonesia: Marine Transportation Point of View. In Proceedings of the 11th International Seminar on Ocean, Coastal Engineering, Environmental and Natural Disaster Management 2023 (Vol. 1298, pp. 1-11). IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science. https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/1298/1/012018
McConnell, A., & Hart, P. t. (2019). Inaction and Public Policy: Understanding Why Policymakers ‘Do Nothing’. Policy Sciences, 52(4), 645-661. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-019-09362-2
McConville, M., & Chui, W. H. (Eds.). (2017). Research Methods for Law (Second Edition). Edinburgh University Press.
Nahar, M. (2025, February 19). Syahwat Politik di Balik Revisi UU Minerba. Jatam. Retrieved May 15, 2025, from https://jatam.org/id/lengkap/Syahwat-Politik-UU-Minerba
Parapat, J., & Hasan, K. (2023). Emerging Captive Coal Power: Dark Clouds on Indonesia’s Clean Energy Horizon. Global Energy Monitor & Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air. https://energyandcleanair.org/publication/emerging-captive-coal-power-in-indonesia
Pattynama, F. M. (2025). Tanggung Jawab Hukum Perusahaan Pertambangan dalam Reklamasi Pasca Tambang di Indonesia. Journal of Mandalika Literature, 6(1), 152-163. Retrieved from https://ojs.cahayamandalika.com/index.php/jml/article/view/3742
Prasetiani, D. N., Anindya, H. F., & Yoshe, A. S. (2024). Strategi Menghadapi Middle Income Trap: Dampak Hilirisasi Mineral terhadap Pendapatan Negara Indonesia Era Joko Widodo. Indonesia Foreign Policy Review, 11(1), 103-117. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14562414
Prasetya, D. A., & Hamka, H. (2023). Kebijakan Pemerintah Indonesia Menghentikan Ekspor Bijih Nikel Ke Uni Eropa (2019). Jurnal Socia Logica, 3(4), 1-10. Retrieved from https://jurnal.anfa.co.id/index.php/jurnalsocialogica/article/view/1313
Presidential Decision of the Republic of Indonesia Number 1 of 2025 on the Task Force for the Acceleration of Downstreaming and National Energy Security. https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/details/311880/keppres-no-1-tahun-2025
Presidential Regulation of the Republic of Indonesia Number 77 of 2024 on the Acceleration of Development and Management of Nursery Facilities for Mineral and Coal Mining Business Activities (State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2024 Number 136). https://peraturan.go.id/id/perpres-no-77-tahun-2024
Qamar, N., & Rezah, F. S. (2020). Metode Penelitian Hukum: Doktrinal dan Non-Doktrinal. CV. Social Politic Genius (SIGn).
Rahma, H., Fauzi, A., Juanda, B., & Widjojanto, B. (2021). Fenomena Natural Resource Curse dalam Pembangunan Wilayah di Indonesia. Jurnal Ekonomi dan Pembangunan Indonesia, 21(2), 148-163. https://doi.org/10.21002/jepi.2021.10
Rantala, K. (2025). Regulatory Impact Assessment and Policymaking Research. Open Access Government, 45(1), 244-245. https://doi.org/10.56367/oag-045-11835
Regulation of Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources of the Republic of Indonesia Number 26 of 2018 on the Implementation of Good Mining Practice and the Supervision of Mineral and Coal Mining (Bulletin Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2018 Number 596). https://peraturan.go.id/id/permen-esdm-no-26-tahun-2018
Regulation of Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6 of 2024 on the Completion of the Construction of Domestic Metallic Mineral Refining Facilities (Bulletin Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2024 Number 282). https://peraturan.go.id/id/permen-esdm-no-6-tahun-2024
Regulation of Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources of the Republic of Indonesia Number 6 of 2025 on Amendment to Regulation of Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources Number 6 of 2024 on the Completion of the Construction of Domestic Metallic Mineral Refining Facilities (Bulletin Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2025 Number 149). https://peraturan.go.id/id/permen-esdm-no-6-tahun-2025
Regulation of Minister of Trade of the Republic of Indonesia Number 22 of 2023 on Goods Prohibited for Export (Bulletin Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2023 Number 526). https://peraturan.go.id/id/permendag-no-22-tahun-2023
Regulation of Minister of Trade of the Republic of Indonesia Number 10 of 2024 on Amendment to Regulation of Minister of Trade Number 22 of 2023 on Goods Prohibited for Export (Bulletin Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2024 Number 288). https://peraturan.go.id/id/permendag-no-10-tahun-2024
Regulation of Minister of Trade of the Republic of Indonesia Number 20 of 2024 on the Second Amendment to Regulation of Minister of Trade Number 22 of 2023 on Goods Prohibited for Export (Bulletin Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2024 Number 511). https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Details/299432/permendag-no-20-tahun-2024
Regulation of Minister of Trade of the Republic of Indonesia Number 8 of 2025 on the Third Amendment to Regulation of Minister of Trade Number 22 of 2023 on Goods Prohibited for Export (Bulletin Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia of 2025 Number 166). https://peraturan.go.id/id/permendag-no-8-tahun-2025
Retnosari, A., Salman, R., & Syaif, H. R. A. (2024). Penggunaan Regulatory Impact Analysis: Studi Penyusunan Peraturan Daerah Jawa Timur Tentang Desa Wisata. Halu Oleo Law Review, 8(1), 29-48. https://doi.org/10.33561/holrev.v8i1.105
Sampara, S., & Husen, L. O. (2016). Metode Penelitian Hukum. Kretakupa Print.
Septiani, M., Sugiharto, I., & Taufik, M. (2024). Urgensi Pemetaan Legal Framework dalam Pembentukan Perda. Pancasakti Law Journal, 2(1), 109-116. Retrieved from https://plj.fh.upstegal.ac.id/index.php/plj/article/view/57
Siombo, M. R. (2023). Kajian Hukum Hilirisasi dan Penghentian Ekspor Mineral Logam. JISIP (Jurnal Ilmu Sosial dan Pendidikan), 7(2), 1384-1391. Retrieved from https://ejournal.mandalanursa.org/index.php/jisip/article/view/4915
Sitohang, C., Azis, H., & Hafiz, M. S. (2025). Hilirisasi Komoditi Mineral: Studi Kasus Nikel di Indonesia. Jurnal Ilmiah Ekonomi dan Manajemen, 3(2), 1-12. Retrieved from https://ejurnal.kampusakademik.co.id/index.php/jiem/article/view/3755
Stiglitz, J. E. (2005). Making Natural Resources into a Blessing Rather than a Curse. In S. Tsalik & A. Schiffrin (Eds.), Covering Oil: A Reporter’s Guide to Energy and Development (pp. 13-19). Open Society Institute.
Sugiarto, L. (2023). Kaidah Pelaksanaan: Kerangka Regulasi dan Kelembagaan. In Uji Publik Rencana Induk Pembangunan Kepariwisataan Daerah (RIPPDA) Kabupaten Sarmi, Provinsi Papua, Tahun 2023 – 2038. Kabupaten Sarmi.
Sugiyono. (2012). Metode Penelitian Kuantitatif, Kualitatif, dan R&D. Alfabeta.
Tan, P. H. P. (2022). Macroeconomic Analysis of the Indonesian Nickel Industry Using Depest Analysis. Ultima Management: Jurnal Ilmu Manajemen, 14(2), 308-320. https://doi.org/10.31937/manajemen.v14i2.2933
Tui, R. N. S., & Adachi, T. (2021). An Input - Output Approach in Analyzing Indonesia’s Mineral Export Policy. Mineral Economics, 34(1), 105-112. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13563-020-00226-3
United Nations General Assembly. (1992, January 29). Report of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee for a Framework Convention on Climate Change: Fourth Session on 9 - 20 December 1991 (A/AC.237/15). https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/138838
United Nations General Assembly. (1992, February 28). Report of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee for a Framework Convention on Climate Change: Fifth Session on 18 - 28 February 1992 (A/AC.237/Misc.20). https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/196978
Wau, F. T., Kiton, M. A., Wau, M., & Fau, J. F. (2024). Analisis Strategis Kebijakan Hilirisasi Mineral: Implikasi Ekonomi dan Pengaruhnya terhadap Perekonomian Indonesia. Journal Publicuho, 7(3), 1215-1224. https://doi.org/10.35817/publicuho.v7i3.481
Wijaya, D. A. S., & Suwanan, A. F. (2024). Investigasi Kebijakan Hilirisasi Nikel Indonesia: Studi Perbandingan antara Indonesia dan Amerika Serikat. Maras: Jurnal Penelitian Multidisiplin, 2(4), 1754-1767. https://doi.org/10.60126/maras.v2i4.477
Wondal, N. S. A., Hasibuan, F. Y., & Rungsimanop, P. (2024). The Law of Natural Resources Management for Economic Prosperity: A Critical Analysis of Law No. 3 of 2020 on Mineral and Coal Mining. International Journal of Contemporary Sciences, 1(12), 952-963. https://doi.org/10.55927/ijcs.v1i12.12044
World Trade Organization. (1994, April 15). General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994 (The WTO Agreement: GATT 1994). https://www.wto.org/english/docs_e/legal_e/gatt94_e.htm
Copyright (c) 2025 Choirul Rohmiyanti Pohan, Laga Sugiarto, Arif Hidayat, Martitah Martitah
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
